Cinnamon Stars, chewy, nutty, and perfectly spiced for festive cheer!
American / Baking / Batch Cooking / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Holidays / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Under 15 Minutes / Vegetarian / Winter
Cinnamon Stars
American / Baking / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Holidays / Nut-Free / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Under 15 Minutes / Winter
Anna Gasere Christmas Cookies and Sour Cream Cookies
Classic holiday cookies filled with nostalgic flavor and homemade warmth.
American / Baking / Beginner / Budget Friendly / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Holidays / Nut-Free / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Thanksgiving / Under 15 Minutes / Winter
Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies
Soft, buttery sugar cookies with a perfectly crisp edge, straight from a vintage recipe card!
American / Baking / Budget Friendly / Chocolate / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Nut-Free / Picnic / Potluck / Quick & Easy / Sheet Pan / Snack / Under 15 Minutes / Vegetarian
M&M Cookies
Old-fashioned cookies packed with M&M’s and nuts for a nostalgic, chewy treat.
American / Baking / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Holidays / Nut-Free / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Thanksgiving / Under 15 Minutes / Winter
Lemon Iced Ginger Snap Cookies
A classic gingersnap cookie with a tangy lemon twist, perfect for the holidays.
American / Baking / Chocolate / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Holidays / Nut-Free / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Thanksgiving / Under 15 Minutes / Vegetarian / Winter
Crunchy Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies
A classic crunchy cookie recipe with oats, chocolate chips, and a retro twist.
American / Baking / Chocolate / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Grains & Rice / Nut-Free / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Under 15 Minutes
Semisweet Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies
Soft, chewy, and packed with chocolate, these oatmeal cookies are a timeless favorite.
American / Baking / Beginner / Budget Friendly / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Holidays / Nut-Free / Overnight / Resting Time / Picnic / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Thanksgiving / Under 15 Minutes / Winter
Spice Cookies, Sugar Cookies and Gingerbread Cookies
These old-fashioned spice cookies are full of warm holiday flavors and vintage charm.
American / Baking / Chocolate / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Picnic / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Under 15 Minutes / Valentine's Day / Vegetarian / Winter
Chocolate Drop Cookies and Shortbread Cookies
Homemade chocolate and shortbread cookies from a cherished vintage recipe.