Creamy, custard-style rice pudding baked with cinnamon for an old-fashioned touch.
American / Boiling / Budget Friendly / Comfort Food / Condiment / Sauce / Dip / Easy / Quick & Easy / Simmering / Under 15 Minutes / Under 30 Minutes / Vegetarian
Pancake Syrup from Mary Beth
A rich, homemade pancake syrup with deep flavor from three types of sugar.
American / Baking / Beginner / Budget Friendly / Christmas / Comfort Food / Dairy / Desserts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Holidays / Nuts & Seed / Picnic / Potluck / Stand Mixer / Thanksgiving / Under 45 Minutes / Vegetarian / Winter
Old-Fashioned Homemade Nut Cake
A rich, nutty cake with a soft crumb and old-fashioned charm.
American / Baking / Beginner / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Desserts / Fall / Autumn / Fruit / Picnic / Potluck / Thanksgiving / Under 1 Hour / Vegetarian / Winter
Apple Cake with Butterscotch Topping
A tender apple cake topped with gooey butterscotch morsels makes for the perfect old-fashioned dessert.
American / Baking / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Desserts / Eastern European / Easy / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Fruit / Hanukkah / Jewish / Over 1 Hour / Potluck / Thanksgiving / Vegetarian / Winter
Jewish Apple Bundt Cake with Cinnamon and Fresh Apples
A spiced apple cake layered in a bundt pan with rich vanilla batter and cinnamon-coated apples.
American / Baking / Christmas / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Easy / Edible GIfts / Eggs / Fall / Autumn / Holidays / Nuts & Seed / Potluck / Sheet Pan / Snack / Stand Mixer / Thanksgiving / Under 30 Minutes / Vegetarian / Winter
Jewel Thumbprint Cookies with Raspberry Jam
These buttery cookies sparkle with sweet jam centers and a crunchy nut coating.
American / Baking / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Desserts / Dutch Oven / Eggs / Fruit / Intermediate / Over 1 Hour / Potluck / Simmering / Southern / Stand Mixer / Under 30 Minutes / Vegetarian
Banana Pudding with Homemade Custard and Meringue
Layers of bananas, vanilla wafers, and creamy custard make this Southern banana pudding unforgettable.
American / Baking / Beginner / Birthday / Budget Friendly / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Desserts / Eggs / Nut-Free / Potluck / Stand Mixer / Under 45 Minutes
Hot Milk Sponge Cake
A classic duo of vintage sponge and chocolate cake recipes, each with timeless flavor and simplicity.
American / Baking / Beginner / Birthday / Comfort Food / Crowd Pleasing / Dairy / Desserts / Eggs / Nut-Free / Picnic / Potluck / Stand Mixer / Under 1 Hour / Vegetarian
One-Pound Cake
A tender vintage-style pound cake baked from scratch in a cold oven for perfect rise and golden crust.
5 Ingredients or Less / American / Beginner / Birthday / Comfort Food / Condiment / Sauce / Dip / Copycat Restaurant Recipes / Dairy / Kid-Friendly Cooking / No-Cook / Nut-Free / Quick & Easy / Stand Mixer / Vegetarian
Powdered Sugar Icing Like Enlow’s Bakery
A smooth, fluffy frosting inspired by the classic flavors of Enlow’s Bakery.