
Rainbow Sandwiches are a vibrant tea-time treat that gained popularity in the early to mid-20th century, often appearing at luncheons, bridal showers, or ladies’ teas. These dainty, pastel-hued finger sandwiches were a whimsical way to add color and charm to an otherwise traditional fare. The filling blends anchovies, egg yolks, and butter into a rich paste, which is then colored and spread between slices of crustless white bread. Carefully sliced and layered, these sandwiches offer a charming vintage presentation and a rich, savory flavor.
Ingredients
- 1 tin sardines
- 3 egg yolks (hard-boiled )
- ¼ lb unsalted butter
- 4 anchovies
- 1 pinch carmine (or red food coloring)
- 1 pinch Breton vert (or green food coloring)
- white sandwich bread (crusts removed)
Instructions
Step 1: Make the Filling
- Pound sardines, egg yolks, butter, anchovies, cayenne, and lemon juice in a mortar (or use a food processor) until very smooth.
- Pass the mixture through a hair sieve or fine mesh strainer for a refined texture.
Step 2: Divide & Tint
- Divide the mixture into 3 equal parts. Leave one portion plain (natural color), color one pink with the carmine, and one green with the Breton vert using food coloring.
Step 3: Prepare the Bread
- Use thin slices of buttered white sandwich bread. Trim crusts.
- Chill the sandwiches after assembling for at least 2 hours before cutting.
Step 4: Assemble Sandwiches
- Four slices of buttered bread are required.
- Spread each colored filling on two slices of bread and spread the natural colored filling on a third slice.
- Stack slices (alternating colors) to make multi-layer sandwiches, then press lightly. Stack them in this order: bread-green-bread-natural-bread-pink-bread
- Wrap in wax paper or foil and refrigerate to firm up.
Step 5: Slice & Serve
- Before serving, trim crusts again if needed and slice into fingers or triangles using a sharp knife.
- Wipe blade between cuts for clean edges.
Tips
- Use tinned sardines in oil, not water, for a smoother spread.
- If you dislike anchovies, replace them with a small amount of capers.
- Add a few drops of lemon juice to brighten the flavor.
- For a stronger pink color, replace cochineal with beet juice.
- Chill the spread before assembling so the mixture spreads cleanly.
- Trim the crusts after assembling to maintain neat edges.
- Use very soft white bread or a thin Pullman loaf for an authentic tea-sandwich texture.
- Make it more modern by adding a small amount of fresh herbs (dill or parsley).
- Serve on ice or a cold platter, just like the handwritten note suggests.
- For gluten-free needs, assemble using gluten-free sandwich bread.
Transcription of the Original Recipe

Read or copy the transcription
Rainbow Sandwiches
________________________
1 Tin Sardines
3 hard boiled yolks of egg
1/4 lb. butter.
4 Boned Anchovies
a little carmine
a little Breton vert.
Pound all together in a mortar & pass through a hair sieve, divide
into 3 equal parts & leave one the natural colour, make one part
green & one part pink.
The sandwiches must be cut 2 hours before being cut out unless
you have ice to put them on.
Four slices of buttered bread are required to cut them correctly
These quantities are for two large tins of sardines.
cut the sandwiches in sections, that is slice the 4 pieces of bread
& butter (after spreading them with the mixture) downwards &
cut off the corners.
________________________
Teacake - fingers
2 lbs. flour, 1 dessertspoonful salt, 2 oz. lard, 1 oz. butter, 1 pint of
new milk made warm, 2 eggs,
1 oz barm
1 teasp. castor sugar
3 tablesp. tepid water } work together to a cream & put on top of
stove till it rises.
Rub lard & butter into flour & salt. Work in the barm with a
wooden spoon, Beat the eggs, & add the warm milk, &
stir with the spoon till the mixture falls away clean from it.
Leave to rise near fire at least two hours.From Transcription to Instructions
Hi from Salvaged Recipes. We find the original directions are a concise mortar-and-sieve note that tells you to pound sardines, egg yolks, butter and anchovies, divide into three and tint, and warns to chill two hours before cutting. The instructions keep that method but spell out the steps so you can follow them: pound or pulse, pass through a hair sieve, divide and color, then assemble between four buttered slices and refrigerate for at least two hours before trimming into fingers. The instructions also add a couple of extra seasonings and a suggested stacking order so you know when each flavor and layer goes in.
Nutrition
Calories: 158kcalCarbohydrates: 0.3gProtein: 5gFat: 15gSaturated Fat: 8gPolyunsaturated Fat: 2gMonounsaturated Fat: 4gTrans Fat: 0.5gCholesterol: 127mgSodium: 55mgPotassium: 80mgSugar: 0.05gVitamin A: 469IUCalcium: 75mgIron: 1mg



